Score
| Name | Grade | Opponent | Season | 178 | Matt McCaughey | C turf | North Carlton | 1991/92 | | 157 | Alec Kahn† | A mat | Brandon | 1983/84 | | 147 | Bill Alexander | A turf | Emmanuel | 2000/01 | | 145* | Tim Powell | B turf | Old Haileybury | 1994/95 | | 138 | John Prent | B turf | API | 1987/88 | | 131 | Ross Attrill† | C mat | Southern Socials | 1983/84 | | 128* | Alec Kahn† | B mat | Royal Oak | 1981/82 | | 128 | John Newton | A turf | Richmond City | 1992/93 | | 122* | Alec Kahn† | C mat | Kensington United | 1980/81 | | 121* | Steve Davies† | A turf | Caulfield Grammarians | 2005/06 | | 120* | Alec Kahn† | A mat | North Melbourne PAFS | 1982/83 | | 118 | Steve Wood† | C turf | South Yarra | 2007/08 | | 115 | Alec Kahn† | A mat | Druids | 1982/83 | | 115 | Jeremy King | A turf | Prahran Imperials | 1997/98 | | 113 | Tim Powell | B turf | API | 1991/92 | | 113 | Matt McCaughey | B turf | API | 1992/93 | | 112* | Bill O'Brien | B turf | Burnley CYMS | 1993-94 | | 112 | Iain Campbell | D turf | Burnley CYMS | 2002/03 | | 112 | Alec Kahn† | B turf | Canterbury | 2006/07 | | 112 | Brent Bevis† | A turf | Sacred Heart | 2008/09 | | 111* | Max Pollock | A turf | Richmond City | 1994/95 | | 111* | Matt McCaughey | B turf | Gunbower United | 1998/99 | | 111 | Alec Kahn† | C mat | Nth Melbourne Druids | 1979/80 | | 110* | Alec Kahn† | A mat | Reservoir YCW | 1983/84 | | 108 | Michael Burke | D mat | Lanes Motors | 1982/83 | | 108 | John Prent | A mat | Coburg United | 1983/84 | | 108 | Matt McCaughey | A turf | Fitzroy-Doncaster | 1992/93 | | 107* | John Prent | A mat | Brandon | 1984/85 | | 107* | Maurice Leone† | B turf | MSA | 1999/00 | | 107* | Jonathan Truscott† | A turf | Chilli Dogs | 2003/04 | | 105* | Jim Todd | C turf | Burnley CYMS | 1997/98 | | 105 | John Prent | B mat | Royal Oak | 1981/82 | | 105 | Alec Kahn† | A turf | Fitzroy-Doncaster | 1993/94 | | 105 | Mark Freeman | A turf | Burnley | 1997/98 | | 104 | Paul Lyons | A mat | Brandon | 1983/84 | | 104 | Tim Jordan | C mat | Brunswick District | 1984/85 | | 103 | Wayne Ludbey | C turf | OEC | 1998/99 | | 103 | Greg Powell† | B turf | Power House | 2006/07 | | 102 | Darren Capogreco† | C turf | Glen Iris | 2006/07 | | 102 | Steve Wood† | D turf | Burnley CYMS | 2008/09 | | 101* | Alec Kahn† | C mat | Port Phillip Combine | 1980/81 | | 101 | Alec Kahn† | B mat | Royal | 1981/82 | | 101 | Tim Jordan | C mat | Fulham Wanderers | 1983/84 | | 100* | Michael Burke | C mat | Druids | 1983/84 | | 100* | Michael Langley | C turf | Burnley CYMS | 1996/97 | | 100* | Maurice Leone† | B turf | Parkdale United | 1997/98 | | 100* | Tom Clark† | C turf | Burnley CYMS | 1999/00 | | 100 | Paul Lyons | A mat | Druids | 1982/83 | | 100 | Roger O'Toole | D turf | Maccabi Ajax | 2002/03 | | 100 | Jim Todd | A turf | Sacred Heart | 2003/04 |
(† denotes current player) |